The legal industry, long anchored by the billable hour, is on the cusp of a transformative shift. As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly integrated into legal practices, traditional pricing models are being challenged. This blog explores how AI is reshaping the landscape, offering new opportunities for efficiency and value, and what this means for the future of legal pricing.
For decades, the billable hour has been the cornerstone of legal billing, providing a straightforward method for law firms to charge clients and measure lawyer productivity. However, this model has faced criticism for promoting inefficiency and misaligned incentives. With the advent of AI, the legal industry is witnessing a paradigm shift towards more flexible and value-driven pricing models.
AI adoption in the legal sector is accelerating at an unprecedented rate. According to a ³ÉÈËÓ°Òô survey, 82% of lawyers in the UK are currently using or planning to use generative AI. This marks a significant increase from just 11% in July 2023. The primary driver behind this surge is the potential for AI to streamline routine tasks, such as legal research and document review, allowing lawyers to focus on more complex and strategic work.
Law firms are leveraging AI to enhance efficiency and accuracy in their operations. Jonathan Kewley, Partner and Co-Chair of the Global Tech Group at Clifford Chance, highlights the transformative potential of AI: "The kind of applications we're seeing – the way it's been rolled out, the innovation, the investment – it's off the scale." Firms are using AI to automate document review, conduct legal research, and even assist in drafting contracts. This not only speeds up processes but also reduces the risk of human error.
Download our AI report
As AI becomes an integral part of legal practice, clients are increasingly demanding more transparency and value in billing. The traditional billable hour model, often criticised for its lack of cost predictability, is being challenged by clients who seek more certainty in legal fees. A found that client demand for alternative billing methods has grown by 26% in the UK since the pandemic.
Clients are pushing for alternative fee arrangements such as fixed fees, capped fees, and success-based pricing models. These models offer greater cost certainty and align the interests of law firms and clients. Bob Mignanelli, Chief Operating Officer for Legal at Haleon, emphasises the importance of alternative fee arrangements: "Our starting point is always an alternative fee arrangement, because it gives us price certainty."
The billable hour has long been criticised for encouraging inefficiency and creating a culture of overwork. A 2022 BigHand survey found that 64% of UK law firms reported an increase in billing write-offs, often due to unrecorded or late-entered time. AI's ability to automate routine tasks challenges the necessity of billing by the hour, prompting firms to explore alternative fee arrangements.
Georgia Dawson, senior partner at Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, notes the shift towards alternative billing: "Over the last 10 years there’s definitely been more of a pivot towards alternative fee arrangements and other structures, where clients are looking for more certainty of cost." With AI enhancing efficiency, firms are increasingly adopting fixed fees, capped fees, and success-based pricing models.
Read our report on the billable hour
AI's ability to deliver work faster and more accurately is prompting a re-evaluation of pricing structures. A ³ÉÈËÓ°Òô survey found that 71% of lawyers cited faster work delivery as the top benefit of AI. This efficiency allows firms to offer more competitive pricing, moving away from time-based billing to value-based models.
Bivek Sharma, Chief Technology Officer at PwC, emphasises the value AI brings: "For my team, generative AI tech is a game-changer that enhances our productivity, efficiency and quality of service delivery." As AI continues to streamline legal processes, firms are likely to adopt pricing models that reflect the value delivered rather than the time spent.
Find out more about Lexis+ AI
While AI offers significant benefits, it also presents challenges, particularly around data accuracy and confidentiality. A ³ÉÈËÓ°Òô survey revealed that 76% of UK legal professionals are concerned about inaccurate or fabricated information from AI platforms. To mitigate these risks, firms are implementing robust policies and training programmes to ensure AI tools are used responsibly.
Tom Whittaker, Director at Burges Salmon, highlights the importance of human oversight: "AI can help speed up research and drafting, but the human lawyer is equally responsible for the output." Ensuring that AI tools are grounded in authoritative legal sources with verifiable citations is crucial to maintaining trust and accuracy.
As AI continues to reshape the legal industry, the shift towards value-based pricing models is expected to gain momentum. A ³ÉÈËÓ°Òô survey found that 39% of private practice lawyers expect to adjust their billing practices due to AI, with a focus on deliverables and value added rather than hours worked.
Mark Smith, Director of Strategic Markets at ³ÉÈËÓ°Òô, predicts a shift towards value-based billing: "AI will push the legal industry towards value-based billing models as routine tasks become automated, reducing the time needed to complete them." This transition will require firms to rethink their pricing strategies, offering clients greater transparency and value.
The integration of AI into the legal industry is driving a fundamental shift in pricing models. As firms embrace AI-driven efficiency, the traditional billable hour is giving way to more flexible and value-oriented pricing structures. This transformation presents both challenges and opportunities, requiring firms to navigate the complexities of AI adoption while maintaining professional integrity. Those that successfully leverage AI's capabilities are likely to gain a competitive edge in the evolving legal landscape.
Find out more about Lexis+
* denotes a required field
0330 161 1234